Paleo vs. Atkins

The Paleo Diet vs The Atkins Diet – Which one is right for you?

As many of you know, I started following the paleo or primal diet in 2011. It’s based on ancestral health and whole foods. Recently I’ve been asked for the difference between The Paleo Diet and the Atkins Diet. I’ve never tried the Atkins diet or given it much thought so I went to http://www.atkins.com.

The two diets appear quite similar at first glance but after further research I discovered that they are actually quiet different. The biggest difference is that the Atkins’s Diet has 4 phases. Phase 1 (Induction), is the most restrictive and it progresses to phase 4 (Lifetime Maintenance) which is the least restrictive. The Paleo Diet does not have any phases, only modifications for people who are athletes, suffer from auto-immune diseases or would like to lose weight. Essentially everyone follows the same guidelines for life.

The Paleo Diet vs The Atkins Diet

Carbs – low-moderate depending on your goal (Paleo) vs low in phase 1 and moderate for phase 4 (Atkins)

Protein – moderate (Paleo) vs moderate (Atkins)

Fat – moderate – high (Paleo) vs high (Atkins)

The Paleo Diet encourages organic vegetables and fruit. The Atkins diet encourages vegetables but doesn’t allow fruit until phase 2.

The Paleo diet emphasizes grass fed, hormone-free and free range meat. The Atkins diet doesn’t really talk about meat quality. Both diets promote eggs and fish.

The types of fat recommended is another way the two diets differ. The Paleo Diet emphasizes saturated fat like coconut butter, grass fed butter as well as olive oil and oil from nuts and seeds. Vegetable oils like canola, grapeseed, soybean, sunflower, and safflower are not approved. The Atkins diet promotes vegetable oils as well as butter.

Dairy is generally not permitted on the Paleo Diet but cheese is allowed in phase 1 and heavy cream in phase 2 of the Atkins Diet.

Are these phases getting confusing yet?

What about grains and bread?

The Paleo Diet doesn’t allow any. The Atkins diet lets you have some in phase 3 and 4.

How about legumes?

None for the Paleo Diet and The Atkins Diet allows them in phase 3 and 4.

What about sugar and artificial sweeteners?

Neither of the diets encourages sugar but The Atkins Diet says that SPLENDA (artificial sweetener) and diet sodas are permitted.

Which diet is right for you?

It depends on what your goals are.

Are you only trying to lose weight or are you interested in healing your digestive system or improving your athletic performance?

Can you live without cheese and Diet Coke?

Do you care about the quality of your food or are okay with eating processed food and food from factory farms?

Okay, I admit I am just a little biased towards one of these diets. If you would like more information on the Paleo Diet please feel free to contact me. The bottom line is that there isn’t one diet that will work for everyone. Each of us is unique and has slightly different nutritional needs.  Dig out your food journal and start taking notes. Who knows what you will discover about yourself?

24 Comments

  1. Hi,
    I started Atkins Diet in January 2012; mother Type 2 Diabetic; I am 1.74m and 63kg, 13%body fat, training for Ironman SA in April 2012.
    Feel good on diet, however still have ‘letharic’ days and feel lethargic at start of my runs, rides and swims, but after 30 mins feel great and feel better as the hours tick by. Sure my carbs are too low – but I put on weight easily with carbs.
    Carbs : 20g – 50g/day
    What carb level should I maintain for training and what type of carbs do you use for training?. I have changed to Hammer Nutrition since Feb for long rides and runs with water; and shorter rides and runs use water.
    Thank you
    Tracy

    • Hi Tracy,

      Your carbs do look low for someone who is training for an Ironman. Sports nutrition is not my specialty but I would go by how you feel and perform. Baked sweet potatoes, dates and bananana are good sources for carbs. I’m not sure what Hammer Nutrition is but I’m guessing it’s a type of sport gel. I personally don’t enjoy sport gels but if you need quick convenient fuel they do the trick.

      Good luck with your training!

      Anastasia

  2. Hi! This is my first visit to your blog! We are a collection of volunteers and starting a new project in a community in the same niche. Your blog provided us beneficial information to work on. You have done a wonderful job!

  3. This web site is really a walk-through for all of the info you wanted about this and didn’t know who to ask. Glimpse here, and you’ll definitely discover it.

    • 5 grams of carbs is not enough, in 4 days your still not FULLY in Ketosis. Your alweold 20 grams a day, EAT 20 grams a day. Don’t play with the diet. Your craving because your blood sugar is still all over the place. If you were following the diet correctly your blood sugar would have probably leveled off by now and you wouldn’t be craving. If you don’t have the Actual book in hand, get it and FOLLOW it, don’t improvise. Until your in full Ketosis your body is going through starvation (yes, even though your eating). Doing what your doing with the carbs can be very dangerous. follow the diet correctly. I lost 80lbs is 12 weeks staying in Phase 1 the whole time, but again if you improvise you asking for failure. There’s no shortage of people who think they know more than Dr. Atkins himself so they screw with the diet, then blame IT for it’s failure. Or when the weight comes right back because they didn’t listen.Do it RIGHT and you’ll be very happy with the results, keep up what your doing and you will guarantee a failure, or a trip to the hospital.

      • Celia, not sure what you’re talking about here. I had to go to zero carbs, as suggested by Dr. Atkins in his New Diet Revolution 2002 version of his diet, in order to go into full ketosis and adapt. I tried 20 carbs a day and it kept me on the verge, feeling like crap, but never going into true ketosis. Once I cut out all carbs, I went within 3 days. After I adapted, I started adding carbs back into my diet. I feel great, am losing weight, and I haven’t looked back since.

  4. It is not difficult to understand the relevant techniques of visualization and have the ability to visualize weight reduction it simply takes just a little practice and this powerful resource can quite literally assist you to to change your own perception of yourself and help you to lose pounds.

    • You look radiant! Well done and stay with it. I wish more peploe would accept that our mega-portioned carb-laden western diet is killing us! And what’s the issue when you can have a fresh, delicious, wholesome diet and treats without one calorie to count. Daily exercise and LOTS OF WATER are also central to successful weight loss and body sculpting. Atkins is a way of life for me and has been for years. Thanks for your video jouney it’s been emotional!

    • YES -Atkins Diet (FAILED)YES -Weight Watchers (FAILED)NO -Slimb7Fast Optima DietNO -Sugar BustersNO -South Beach DietYES Calorie Restricted Diet (FAILED)YES Whole Plant Based Diet (THE WINNER)NOTE:The only diet that worked for me was a diet cellad a low-fat whole plant based diet that has been endorsed by Dr. Dean Ornish, Dr. Neal Barnard, Dr. Joel Fuhrman, Dr. John McDougall, and Professor T. Colin Campbell. Read any of these outstanding biochemists and nutrition experts for details. If you read Gina Kolata’s book Rethinking Thin you will learn that over the long-term, none of the commercially popular diets worked for most people. People, even those who are highly motivated, cannot stay on these diets because they are temporary and cannot be sustained.I will answer the following questions with regard to a Whole Plant Based diet as described by Dr. Caldwell Esselstyn, Jr.1.Why did you initially choose this diet?At a dinner party, a distinguish retired physician pulled me aside and expressed concern for my health because of my excess weight. As an active triathelete, he had instant credibility. He recommended that I read Dr. Dean Ornish. I started the diet, the next day. Since that day, I moved through the authors I listed above who recommend essentially the same diet.2.What is the basic premise of this diet/eating plan?Avoid food like substances that are over processed. Avoid excess sugar, fat/oil, salt, caffeine, alcohol, refined carbohydrates, MSG, aspartame, drugs, food contaminants, food additives, dairy, eggs, and all other forms of animal protein. Instead eat the following foods:+ Leafy greens Kale, Collards High in iron, calcium, and protein.+ Legumes Peas, Beans, Lentils Bean sprouts are delicious and nutritious+ Whole Grains Brown Rice, Buckwheat, and non-gluten whole grains (not instant and overprocessed)+ Colorful Vegetables Steamed and raw+ Vitamin B12 and D as needed+ Ground Flax Seed for Omega-3 Essential Fatty Acids (avoid all other fats and oils)+ Drink pure well water avoiding municipal water supplies treated with chlorine and fluoride3. What were two positive aspects of the diet?+ This is a lifestyle change and the motivation to stay on the diet is built in. It’s how good you feel.+ No calorie counting+ No feeling of deprivation+ Prevention and reversal of cardiovascular disease and diabetes. (Dr. Caldwell Esselstyn, Jr.)+ Blood work is automatically moved toward health4.Were there any downsides to the diet plan? Explain.It requires that you learn how to cook and not use some common ingredients. Eating out can be a problem, but you can find ethnic restaurants that serve healthier foods.5.Did you have success on this diet?Yes. I lost 90 pounds, regained my sense of smell, no longer have sinus infections, and have perfect blood work.6.Are you still on the diet plan?It’s my new lifestyle, not a temporary diet.7.Have you maintained your weight loss?Yes. I am now moving on to portion control. I plan to eat just two meals per day. A big breakfast and an afternoon meal.8.Do you feel the diet is safe? Why or why not?It is absolutely the safest and healthiest way to eat. The authors and experts I cited above are independent of food industry interests. The diet is optimal for everyone, skinny or fat.9.Did you exercise while on the diet?I exercise aerobically five times per week for an hour at a time. I bicycle to work every day.10.Would you follow this diet plan again?It’s the only diet for me. If you diet for a temporary period of time, you can be assured that the weight will rebound. You must make the diet a lifestyle choice.

    • Before I found the diet solution plan, I ate a diet conitssing of a dangerously low amount of fat each day. I thought all fat was bad. Now I know Almonds, Flax seeds & Walnuts are good for me! At first I was scared to eat HEALTHY fats but once I did the pounds started coming off to my surprise! Calories used to be the first thing I looked at on a box, not caring what the ingredients were.

  5. Thank you for this infomation

    • I’m a thin 43 year old woman. Since my 20s, I’ve had an interest in nuotriitn and learned a lot of things since then. I also began to see fat on my stomach and over the years it never disappeared, in fact I began to see more! I would go to the gym, but nothing would happen. I really learned a lot with the DSP. I adore pasta , bread and cereals and was able to make it through the 14 days without them! I lost 3.1 cm on my waist. I feel better now without wheat, as I am not bloated. I love all the information I’ve read to help me to achieve my goals of burning fat and being in good health. Thank you

  6. Good read, I just passed this onto a colleague who was performing some research on that. And he in fact bought me lunch as I identified it for him smile So let me rephrase that: Thank you for lunch! 90827

  7. quite very good publish, i in fact really like this internet internet site, carry on it 194148

  8. Thank you a bunch for sharing this with all people you really know what you are speaking approximately! Bookmarked. Kindly additionally discuss with my website =). We can have a link change contract between us

  9. Heya i am for the primary time here. I found this board and I find It
    truly useful & it helped me out much. I am hoping to provide one thing again and aid others like you helped me.

  10. Thanks for a marvelous posting! I really enjoyed reading it, you may be a great author.

    I will be sure to bookmark your blog and will come back in the foreseeable future.
    I want to encourage that you continue your great
    writing, have a nice holiday weekend!

  11. Only wanna remark that you have a very nice site, I love the pattern it actually stands out.

  12. nice site the text becomes a bit hard to read on your background after a while tho. jus a friendly suggestion =)

  13. I am on Atkins, eat only organic vegetables and fruits, grass fed meats, do not use vegetable oils with the exception of olive oil, do not eat grains nor nuts due to allergies, but do eat dairy products, such as cheese and cream. I’ve been eating whole organic foods for years – even before I went low carb. Not everybody on Atkins eats processed crappy foods or conventionally grown/raised foods. What turned me off to Paleo is the no dairy, which is why I went with Atkins.

Social Widgets powered by AB-WebLog.com.